One of the most common questions that we get as a custom home builder regarding the exterior is regarding brick and hardie board in Charleston. Which option offers the best value, durability, and aesthetics for your custom home?
This article compares brick and Hardie Board across cost, maintenance, installation, appearance, and environmental impact.
By the end, you’ll have the knowledge to make an informed choice that aligns with your home’s needs and your personal preferences.
Oak Angel Builders understands the importance of selecting the right siding material for your custom home, whether it’s traditional brick or modern cement-based options like Hardie Board.
What are the Pros and Cons of Brick and Hardie Board?

Cost Comparison
Brick costs more than fiber cement siding, with materials and installation expenses being higher. The need for specialized labor and mortar adds to the overall price of brick construction. Fiber cement siding, such as Hardie Board, offers a more budget-friendly option. Its lightweight nature reduces installation costs, and it requires less maintenance over time compared to brick.
While brick provides superior heat retention, potentially lowering energy costs, fiber cement siding’s affordability, and wood-like appearance make it an attractive alternative for cost-conscious homeowners. The choice between the two often depends on budget constraints and long-term value considerations.
The total cost comparison varies by region and availability of skilled laborers. In some areas, particularly Texas, brick can actually be less expensive than Hardie board due to the abundance of experienced masons
Durability and Maintenance
Durability and maintenance are crucial factors when comparing brick and Hardie Board for wall construction. Brick can last up to 100 years when properly maintained, while Hardie Board typically lasts 40-50 years.
Brick’s resilience against termites and weathering contrasts with Hardie Board’s resistance to rot and ease of renovation. Understanding these differences helps homeowners make cost-effective choices for their polyvinyl chloride alternatives.
Both materials are fire-resistant, though brick has superior fire resistance, being able to withstand direct flames for over an hour. Hardie Board requires repainting every 7-10 years, while brick requires mortar joint repointing every 25-30 years.
Brick Advantages
Brick offers exceptional durability and low maintenance requirements, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners. Its natural waterproofing properties protect against moisture infiltration, reducing the need for additional stucco or paint applications.
It’s also one of the most eco-friendly options available, being made from natural materials like clay and shale. Additionally, brick provides superior sound insulation and qualifies homes for insurance discounts in many areas.
Brick’s longevity often surpasses that of other materials, providing long-term value despite higher initial costs:
Aspect | Brick | Hardie Board |
---|---|---|
Durability | Excellent | Good |
Maintenance | Low | Moderate |
Moisture Resistance | High | Moderate |
Hardie Board Advantages
Hardie Board offers distinct advantages in durability and maintenance. Composed of concrete, sand, and clay, this fiber cement siding resists rot, warping, and insect damage.
Many manufacturers provide extensive warranties, often up to 50 years, demonstrating confidence in the product’s longevity.
Hardie Board’s energy efficiency contributes to lower utility costs, making it an attractive option for homeowners seeking long-term value:
Feature | Benefit |
---|---|
Composition | Resistant to rot and pests |
Warranty | Up to 50 years |
Energy Efficiency | Reduced utility costs |
Installation
The installation processes for brick and Hardie Board differ significantly. A complete brick wall installation takes 3-5 weeks from planning to completion. Hardie Board installation can be completed more quickly, though it requires specific expertise as improper installation can void warranties
Brick
Brick installation requires skilled masonry professionals and typically takes longer than vinyl siding or Hardie Board. The process involves laying individual bricks with mortar, which demands precision and expertise. Climate considerations are crucial, as extreme temperatures can affect mortar curing. While brick construction offers excellent durability and potential insurance benefits, it often involves higher initial costs compared to alternative materials.
Hardie Board
Hardie Board installation offers several advantages in terms of aesthetics and durability. This fiber cement siding comes pre-painted in a wide range of colors, enhancing curb appeal while simplifying the installation process. The installation requires specific tools and expertise, as the material is significantly heavier than traditional siding – 100 square feet weigh approximately 300 pounds compared to 60-70 pounds for vinyl siding.
Appearance
The appearance of brick and Hardie Board significantly impacts a building’s aesthetics and potential return on investment. Brick offers a classic, timeless look suitable for various architectural styles. Hardie Board, a composite material, provides versatility in design and color options. Both materials can enhance curb appeal, influencing roofing choices and complementing bathroom remodel projects.
Brick
Brick offers a timeless aesthetic that enhances a home’s curb appeal and value. Its natural variations in color and texture create a sophisticated look that withstands the test of time, even in areas prone to hail.
Unlike metal siding, brick provides a solid, grounded appearance that complements various architectural styles. James Hardie Industries recognizes brick’s enduring appeal, which often influences their product designs for fiber cement siding options.
Hardie Board
Hardie Board offers a versatile appearance that mimics the look of wood shingles without the maintenance concerns associated with cellulose-based materials. Its engineered composition resists mold growth, eliminating the need for frequent repointing common with brick facades.
Homeowners can choose from a wide range of colors and textures, allowing for customization that complements various architectural styles while maintaining a low-maintenance exterior.
Environmental Impact
The environmental impact of brick and Hardie Board varies significantly. Brick, known for its durability, offers excellent insulation properties and is often considered environmentally friendly due to its long lifespan.
Hardie Board, a fiber cement product, provides water resistance and insect protection. Both materials have implications for sustainability, energy efficiency, and waste reduction in construction.
Brick
Brick manufacturing processes have evolved to reduce environmental impact, incorporating recycled materials and energy-efficient kilns. The thermal mass of brick contributes to energy savings in homes, regulating indoor temperatures and reducing heating and cooling costs.
Proper flashing techniques during installation enhance the brick’s durability, extending its lifespan and minimizing the need for replacements in kitchen and home improvement projects. The environmental benefits of brick include:
Aspect | Environmental Benefit |
---|---|
Longevity | Reduced waste over time |
Thermal Mass | Lower energy consumption |
Recyclability | Decreased landfill impact |
Hardie Board
Hardie Board offers environmental benefits through its composition and durability. Made from sustainable materials like cement, sand, and cellulose pulp, it resists pests and moisture, reducing the need for chemical treatments often used in drywall or wood siding. Its longevity minimizes replacement frequency, decreasing overall waste.
Hardie Board’s versatility extends to bathroom applications, where it can serve as a stable backing for tile installations, contributing to more sustainable home improvement practices.
Need expert guidance on choosing between brick and Hardie Board for your home’s exterior? Trust Oak Angel Builders.

When deciding between brick’s timeless durability and Hardie Board’s modern versatility, you need a contractor who understands both materials inside and out. Oak Angel Builders specializes in both brick masonry and Hardie Board installation, delivering superior craftsmanship tailored to Charleston’s unique climate challenges.
Making the right choice for your home’s exterior is crucial for long-term value and protection. Our experienced team can help you weigh the benefits of brick’s century-long lifespan and natural insulation against Hardie Board’s design flexibility and lower maintenance requirements. Our recent projects were at Johns Island and Riverland Terrace near Fields Farm Market and Fort Pemberton.
Plus, with our comprehensive 5-year workmanship guarantee and certified installation expertise that can also handle local permits, you can trust that your home’s exterior will maintain its beauty and protection for years to come. Let Oak Angel Builders help you make the informed choice for your home’s exterior today.